A Comparison of Common and ۳۶۰-Degree Evaluation Methods in terms of Clinical Skills of Surgical Technology Students in Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Iran, in ۲۰۱۳

Background & Objective: The use of an integrated and approved method in clinical evaluation is of great importance. The aim of this research was the comparison of the ۳۶۰- degree and common evaluation methods in clinical skills evaluation of undergraduate surgical technology students in Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Iran, during the operating room technical training course. Methods: This single group interventional study was performed on ۴th semester students in surgical technology at Kerman University of Medical Sciences in the operating room of Shahid Bahonar Hospital of Kerman. The data collection tool consisted of a questionnaire which was completed by ۲۴ students and ۲ lecturers.. Data were analyzed using SPSS software and paired and independent t-tests. Results: Findings showed that mean age of students was ۲۱.۲۰ ± ۰.۵۶ years and most of them were females. Mean and standard deviation of total score of the common and ۳۶۰-degree evaluation methods were ۱۷.۶۶ ± ۰.۸۶ and ۱۷.۸۸ ± ۰.۸۸, respectively. There was no significant differences between the mean scores of these methods (P = ۰.۰۰۱). Students had relative satisfaction with the ۳۶۰-degree evaluation method (score = ۶.۱۲ ±  ۶۴.۷۷) and relative dissatisfaction with the common evaluation method (score = ۳۸.۱۱ ± ۰۸.۴۹). There was a significant difference between students satisfaction with these two methods (P  < ۰.۰۰۱). Lecturers had relative dissatisfaction with the common evaluation method (score = ۴۷.۵۱ ± ۶.۶۴) and complete satisfaction with the ۳۶۰-degree evaluation method (score = ۸۵.۹۸ ± ۹.۸۴). Conclusion: The students’ ۳۶۰-degree evaluation score was similar to that obtained through their evaluation by lecturers. Considering students’ relative satisfaction and lecturers’ total satisfaction with the ۳۶۰-degree method, in comparison to their relative dissatisfaction with the common method, it seems that using this method can be effective in the modification of their dissatisfaction with the current clinical evaluation method.

کلیدواژه ها:

Common evaluation ، ۳۶۰-degree evaluation ، Student evaluation ، Operating Room